Mayella also claimed in her testimony that Tom Robinson had beat her and choked her so aggressively that she could not escape from him. Yet, once Atticus began questioning her, it seemed very unlikely that Robinson could attack her. For instance, when Atticus asked Tom to stand up, Jem exclaimed "Scout, look! Reverend, he's crippled!" (Lee 186). Tom Robinson's left arm was a foot shorter than his right and his hand was shriveled up. If Mayella had said that she was beaten on the right side of her face and it's likely that the criminal hit her with his left, then it would make absolutely no sense that Tom Robinson had hurt her. Mayella's testimony overall seemed very unreliable, which makes me wonder what the outcome will be.
Sunday, December 7, 2014
Question 1: Mayella's Testimony
In chapters 18 and 19 of To Kill A Mockingbird, the author begins to go into more detail of the witnesses in the Tom Robinson case. One of the witnesses seemed very unsure and hesitant, and this witness was none other than Miss Mayella Ewell. Mayella is the victim of rape in the trial, but when she got on the stand she was unclear of the events that occurred, even though she witnessed them herself. For example, when Atticus asked her, "Who beat you up? Tom Robinson or your Father?" she did not answer (Lee 187). Because Mayella is the one who 'got raped', it's almost impossible for her to not know who the culprit is. This event seemed very strange to me, but is very interesting because if she did lie on the witness stand, she could get in major trouble.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment