Monday, September 8, 2014

MEAEAT

M- Queen Bees and Wannabes by Rosalind Wiseman should not be read by freshmen in high school       because of its stereotypical and unrealistic scenarios.
E- Wiseman provides a picture of a "typical" high school cafeteria with separated lunch tables, including one table for asian nerds, one table for JV jocks, etc. (pg 104 and 105)
A- From this evidence, it is clear that Wiseman is over exaggerating the idea of lunch tables. There has never been a high school in which each cultural or racial group sat at a different table, which will make students feel like they have to belong to one group of people to be able to sit at their lunch table.
E- Wiseman describes cliques as being cruel and says "as soon as you define your role and group, you perceive others as outsiders." (pg 101)
A- Considering this example, one can see how Wiseman places each girl in a specific category, and she describes each and every clique as being terribly rude and mean. However, not all cliques have the same structure, and most "cliques" are very nice and mind their own business. This will cause teenagers to feel as if every other clique is malicious, and will feel the need to fit in even more.
T- In other words, Wiseman has presented many extreme scenarios, which is why freshmen in high school should not read Queen Bees and Wannabes.


M- Because of its poor organization, Queen Bees and Wannabes by Rosalind Wiseman should not be read by freshmen in high school.
E- This book contained many broad chapters, with information that does not relate to the chapter title at all. One chapter is entitled "Girl World Meets Boy World" in which Wiseman discusses how to confront a friend about gossiping using a technique called SEAL. (pg 316)
A- This evidence is important because when reading the book, the reader can become very confused and not understand the main idea completely. Because of this unorganized work, the reader will get lost and miss the entire message.
E- The author also provides random phrases such as "Act Like A Woman Box" and "Check Your Baggage" in which she does not explain very thoroughly. However, these expressions will pop up regularly throughout the novel. (pg 100 and 106)
A- From this evidence, it is blatantly obvious how the author does not have a good hand on organization. Nobody will know what these terms mean, which makes it very difficult to make a connection between the reader, and what the author is trying to portray or explain.
T-Wiseman constructed the unorganized and hard to understand Queen Bees and Wannabes, and it should not be read by freshmen in high school.


M- Queen Bees and Wannabes by Rosalind Wiseman should not be read by freshmen in high school because of its directed material towards parents.
E- Wiseman makes it very clear in this book that all "girls are obnoxious and hormone crazy", and that all daughters "threaten to run away" (pg 2)
A-The book is an actual guide for mothers, so it provides many tips for moms, and not for teenage girls. This makes the book very hard to relate to, because almost all teenage girls are not mothers.
E- Many connections to the 80's are mad win this novel, such as "as adults, we can laugh at how immense and insurmountable problems like this luck tray moments can feel when you're young." (pg 11)
A- Considering this example, one can see how freshmen girls reading this book would not be able to understand or connect to these flashback scenarios. Only parents reading this book could relate, which makes it difficult for girls to read.
T- Queen Bees and Wannabes by Rosalind Wiseman is a book for parents, which is why it should not be read by freshmen in high school.

No comments:

Post a Comment